I write with great sadness today because later this morning I am required to go into court to defend myself against charges which may or may not have been rightfully brought against me by a policewoman.
My sadness, however, stems from the fact that I was arrested, charged and held - but denied the right to lay charges in return, even though the woman (who was not in uniform and was driving an unmarked car) failed to stop at a stop sign and as a result damn near knocked me off my bicycle.
The speed with which both of us were travelling, I could have been killed.
I, you see, had the right of way - but it seems I do not have the rights of an ordinary citizen because I chose to tangle with a cop.
My experience of six hours in the cells is of brutal, willfully stupid people who are entirely unable to defend the law without resorting to bullying and who are completely incapable of applying the law because they are cowards who choose to attack only soft targets.
It’s not as if mine is an isolated case (read the papers any day). I live, and had the bad luck to pound the roof of my potential killer’s car, in Knysna. But on Sunday, a colleague in the media was arrested and held for eight hours in Durban for taking a photograph of a cop who was engaged in smashing up the traders’ tables in a market that has been operating legitimately for 17 years. The reason she took his photo? He wasn’t wearing a name badge, and she wanted to be able to identify him in court.
(It’s a measure of the stupidity of the man that after she was released, the reporter found that she still had his photo on her camera).
The cells are inhumane. The conditions under which alleged criminals are held are inhumane. And the system is inhumane.
At the Global Media Face-Off at this year’s Indaba, I said this to the commissioner of police: we all know that South Africa has the ability to safely host mass events (witness the Rugby and Cricket World Cups, and the IPL). But what about policing at street level? What is being done about the level of crime in our homes?
He was unable to offer a satisfactory response.
And now I’ll add this: if the cops, the police, are unable to obey the law at the lowest level (stopping at a stop street, for goodness sake!), how is South Africa to guarantee the safety of our visitors into the future? (you see it all the time - WHO stops at a stop street in South Africa? And if the cops can’t - who’s setting the example?).
With 366 days to go to the kickoff for FIFA’s World Cup - which is undoubtedly the biggest opportunity that will come our way in our lifetimes - and with our police behaving the way they do, how the hell is this country going to guarantee the safety of the world when it visits us in 2010?
I’ll be thinking, as I go into court this morning, as I go into the maw of a system that is corrupt, ineffective and inefficient, of how the tourism industry in this country will fare into the future.
And I think my answer will be that unless we - the industry - take up the question of crime and, more significantly, of policing (because I’ve learned that crime is a two way street, and that without effective and informed policing, crime will never be controlled), we will deserve the harvest we reap.
Now go away on holiday - it’s in the economy’s best interests…









27 users commented in " This Tourism Week: 9 June 2009 "
Follow-up comment rss or Leave a TrackbackIn the name of tourism, I wish to remain anonymous, but still want to add a few points in solidarity to your predicament.
Place: Union Buildings, Pretoria
Date: Every day
Time: All the time
Observations:
- Police guards at the main entrance (vehicle search area) are lazing around on broken chairs,
often reading newspapers. Mostly wearing unmatched uniforms. (not that any of us now a days
actually knows what is Official uniforms and/or not - looking at the spade of hi-jacking in and around
Pretoria, by “officially dressed cops”)
- There is no sense of pride (I mean, they are after all protecting the President of a country)
- The slouch around without much urgency whenever a car approaches.
- The best I’ve seen (now that it is still very dark at 05h45 in the morning, is the way in which they
search vehicles. The driver does not have to switch off the car, nor are asked to get out. They simply
hold the mirror under the vehicle (I mean, it is dark and there ain’t no lights at the stop/search spot)
and let the car go. (mmm….what about the boot…)
- At the bottom entrance (public) there are x-ray search devises and the works, but still the police are being
guarded by a private unarmed Security firm day and night? (Ehh..?)
Talking about Indaba, It is absolutely shocking how they ‘clean’ out the city during Indaba. Every single
overseas operator thinks Durban is King! But unfortunately, a very few of them actually remains behind
after that Tuesday or Wednesday…they should stay until the weekend after when things are back to
normal and the Police has disappeared in the crowds and every third tourist are being mugged, and every
now and again another gets attacked while the woman is being raped. But thanks to the local tour
guides, (which has to use the best diplomacy) explaining and keeping the tourists off the beachfront
at sunrise and sunset as this is not your ideal sunset-boulevard with margaritas on the beach!
And yes, we had two people ‘arrested’ from our back garden and when the police left and I went
down to the local shop, I walked straight into the same two criminals, which has been dropped off by
the Police. Also the one morning at 3am, when the Police was called out to yet another couple
of ‘window-shoppers’ in the neighbourhood, the policeman asked if we have a torch for him, as
the station does not issue them with any?
I rest my case and wish you the best of luck. It’s such a pity that fighting these people
for rights (which is guaranteed to all of us by the constitution) leaves you broke (court cases
and lawyers), desponded and at the end of the day just to find out it was a total waste of time.
But still we remain South Africans, even if it is only for the sunshine that is still free of charge.
Kind regards,
Anonymous
This makes my blood boil. The woman should be named, shamed, and drummed out of SAPS, as an example to all, if she is in the wrong.
This needs to be read together with a report in Bizcommunity yesterday:
“Peter Vundla, who resigned from the SABC board back in May, took the opportunity following Khanyi Mkhonza’s resignation on Thursday last week to say what he reckons is wrong with the SABC. Among the mildest things he says is his opinion that the broadcaster is like an employment agency; in his first 12 months on the board he saw staff grow by 600, with three people doing the work of one and more managers than he’d ever seen before.
“People have apparently been appointed not for their experience and skills, but on the basis of their political affiliations - which explains a great deal!”
Not everyone is suited to be a policeman or policewoman, nor can they be trained to be one.
The same goes for many of the new entrants to tourism.
Capability and mindset come first.
Martin, this is absolutely crazy - it happend to my partner (An Australian) and i on Feb, 14th at 1130pm. We were minding our own business walking down long street when a cop Car stopped and refused to believe that all we were doing was walking, the cops proceeded to tear my clothes this in full view of a well know restuarant where people started gathering - i was trying to ask ‘what is going on’ instead they claimed that i was humiliating them in public - what followed was a nightmarish experience, 9hrs in a cell - my aussie boyfriend was assualted in the cell and non of the cops spoke English to him even though i told them that he was a foreigner and could not understand afrikaans - i was stripped searched - money removed from my pockets and then pushed into a cell - no rights read , no phone call no assistance given - all this while friends watched in horror. We were then ordered to pay R200 each for admission of guilta nd the only way out of a cell(covered in roaches, urine and mites infected blankets) - to this day we still dont know what we were charged with - ive taken the matter as far as i can - only to be sent a lame contracdicory letter of apology. There is a term called Riotous behaviour that cops can use to arrest citizens,criminals anyone really who either argues or challenges them.
We need to stop this behaviour!!!!
I do not want to leave South Africa, we have so much going, but i cannot trust another person in blue uniform and hate to think that this could happen to someone else.
Please forge ahead with the proposed Police Forum and keep us updated as we right behind you!!
Good Luck!
Althea
Hi Martin
I really do understand the frustration, but let me throw the cat amongst the pigeons. Last night my business partner’s child came down with a really bad flu, my partner told her to stay home as she would self-medicate her as they have no medical aid it is quite expensive consulting doctor (R 250.00) and one still has to buy medicines. The child was unfortunately writing exams today and she says that if she does not produce a doctor’s letter, that she is going to get a zero for the exams as per school rules. Now the mother is running around like a headless chicken trying to find a ‘doctor’s letter’ or, a doctor that will be so kind to the economically indisposed mother as she does not have the cash for a doctor. So the school which is a public institution is directly encouraging this mother to commit fraud, because I can guarantee you that no mother will want to see her child fail and so will commit this kind of fraud( R50 per letter is the going rate). I mean, since when is a letter from the parent not good enough anymore? Now you tell me, is hell still coming or are we living it already.
Sorry that happened to you Martin..what happened today with the hearing ?
I applaud you for writing out loud the examples which we as citizens see ALL THE FRIGGIN time. Police officers not wearing seat belts, speeding, overtaking on double white lines and driving impatiently at very unsafe following distances. ALL of these examples I witnessed just yesterday on the road from Cape Town, but I see at least one incident each time I drive. Further, when traffic offences are committed in clear light of day, and a cop is either in front of me or behind me, the most I have ever seen any cop do is just look, Do something ? I have yet to see it. I even put it to the test. Yesteday a cop in a marked car passed me in a 70km per hour zone, going at about 120. SO I tailed him to see what would happen. But I chickened out after a while because doing so at that speed felt very unsafe on that particular stretch of road. I wasn’t stopped and fined for speeding though. That is what should have happened.
SO you GO!!. Make a noise, talk about it and let’s put pressure on the traffic department to take all these lazy incomepetents to task. It’s the only way to get some sanity back on our roads and save a few lives.
Wendy
Just to add that I am grateful for the diligent officers and policemen who work so hard. It is a pity that a few can tarnish the overall perception and efficacy of the force.
This is a most unfortunate incident Martin, using the power of your writing should expose all this cruel treatment you received and imagine what ordinary folks without a voice go through on a daily basis under police brutality.
Good luck on your court appearance.
Best wishes Martin…..from Nicole and Uschi
Hi there Martin…Ditto to everything you wrote…I too was at the Face Off, heard your question and the evasive answer. And, yes, it seems pointless to be asked to ASK questions with ANSWERS that are usually of the “crab-walking” type…One gets the feeling that the panel believe that any answer will do. Clearly, the Face OFF needs to be renamed the GLOBAL Media EXTRAVAGANZA….where showbizz reigns supreme. Keeping our fingers crossed and that you suffer minimal stress…Let us know how things go…Kind regards…Uschi and Nicole (Cape Info SA)…..
Dear Martin,
Please let us know the out come of your case, as I think that this should be taken further.
Maybe we should start a group for just this. Daily I travel into town (Durban) and see total disregard for traffic signs.
NOBODY except me – and I have to suffer daily abuse for this – stops for pedestrians, and most drivers go through the RED. Pedestrian have no right of way, but unfortunately you have to be knocked over before you can lay a charge.
I don’t think I would like to take this chance, as just the same happened last week when a full taxi went through a pedestrian crossing, hit a pedestrian, went out of control and ploughed into a roadside hawker and then into the pedestrian on the pavement, AND THEN THE DRIVER RAN AWAY!!!! – GUESS WHAT, HE KNEW HE WAS IN THE WRONG, OTHERWISE WHY DID HE RUN? One person KILLED and numerous badly hurt.
As you can see I feel very strongly about this and really think that we should get together and at least try and push the issue with the powers that be.
Your input is greatly appreciated.
Regards
Alison
Durban
Hi Martin,
I am appalled at this treatment. I was in SA in April and travelled around a fair amount by car. PE to Cradock and back and Joburg to Komatipoort and Sabi Sands and back. I was stopped on a number of occasions by “police” and each time treated as though I was a most unwelcome guest in the country. I was once harassed and made to produce my passport as she (a woman cop) accused me of entering the country illegally!! Geez mate I flew in from Australia and she had my Oz drivers Licence!! I was also accused of “speeding” near Hazeyview – I am adamant I was NOT. Also when I asked to see the radar I was told it had already been erased to “catch” another car! I was fined R800 and given the option of getting a receipt from the police station (but I had to wait from 9.00am until 5.00pm to do so as they could not leave the spot they were trapping at) or paying a spot fine but no receipt! I was travelling to a game lodge so could not wait 8 hours to get a receipt so paid the R800 directly to this criminal whom I am certain pocketed it for his own use. I mentioned it to the lodge staff who informed me that this “happens all the time” and that they had complained to the local senior police officer with no effect at all. I understand from the staff that these cops target white visitors in hire cars particularly. True or not I don’t know but I would not be surprised!!
Martin, we are an outbound tour operator who send many clients to SA for Safaris and other holidays and add to the tourism income of South Africa. If the bloody minded police continue to harass tourists the reputation of the country as a tourist destination will suffer further. We already have to manage very carefully the questions “is it safe?”, “will I be high-jacked?” etc.
Making your story public will maybe get the powers that be to take note and finally act rather than just letting the status quo remain.
I hope you made it OK without any more stress.
Kind regards.
John Mitchell-Adams
Nelson Bay. Australia
Having had experience of the sad, sad behaviour of our police force I thought I would add my two pennies worth.
Some years ago ago while traveling to Johannesburg I was talking a call from my office on my cell phone (yes it was wrong but then everybody does it) when two policemen screamed past me and forced me off the road. No marked police car, no back number plate, no uniforms. The one climbed out and worked towards me while the other leaned over his door and aim a gun at me. I had my young son in the car so you can imagine my reaction. Luckily I don’t panic easily and when the bully started on me I simply said that if he was a cop I wanted his name, rank and badge number as I would be laying a complaint with his home station – living in the area I also knew that the then station commander did not take kindly to this type of behaviour from his staff. This was in 1998 so if it was bad then I shudder at present behaviour. I have seen them force people off the road to get past, solid white lines, stop streets, red robots mean nothing, no plates, and carrying wives and children in police vehicles all seem part of the job nowadays.
Then there was the time that several invaded my garden in pursuit of a housebreaker and decided to shoot their high-powered rifles across my paddock where my daughters valuable show horses were grazing. That the thief was running in a different direction didn’t matter, nor did it that it was eventually my Great Dane who made the thief decide that a police van might be a safe place.
I would depend on my six attack dogs before I called the cops.
Hi Martin,
Ek hoop jy dreun hulle goed op daar in die hof! Dit is sommer pure nonsens dat ons moet toelaat om so mishandel te word deur onkapabele en onbeskofte lede van die polisie en verkeersdepartement. Hulle is duidelik nie opgelei in menseverhoudinge nie en het nie ‘n benul van wat professionaliteit behels nie.
Groete
G
Hi Martin,
I trust all went well at court and that you were able to give that “policewoman” a real roasting…. She is a disgrace to the uniform she wears. I am proud to say I live in Prince Albert where our police force are fantastic they go out of their way to make our town a better place.
Kind regards,
Lisa
Onse Rus
Prince Albert
Just to say I am appalled at the incident you describe: so many cyclists are being knocked down and killed these days. There have been many memorial rides in the Cape recently. You have my support in any actions to try and stop the type of intimidation you describe. Win your Case for a start. Bokkie
All the best Martin. Give ‘em stick!
Christina Pretorius
Head of Programmes
IFAW Southern Africa
+27 21 424 2086
+27 82 330 2558
With regards to this weeks newsletter: I hope this was reported to SATSA and SA Tourism. We need to make a BIG noise about this!!
Oh wow Martin, you poor man. I feel for you and everyone else who has these experiences.
My elder son, who does not drink, was arrested and held in a cell overnight, with out being charged, other than the policeman who said.”he was drunk in a public place”. ( year or so ago)
We are most fortunate here in our paradise now. Our local police Captain is a woman, and she brooks no nonsense at all. One can call her up anytime and she attends to all complaints.
She has made so many changes to the area and we cherish her. The police station is spotless, the staff brilliant and so helpful.
‘jest asking, but maybe it is beacuse she has so much to prove? Are there any other women police captains around?
Sorry to hear about this Martin - hope all goes well! Good luck!
Martin
Sorry to hear about your predicament, but have some faith, some Magistrates see through these inefficient slime balls. I hear that the Knysna police are especially brutal, from a friend of mine whose son was arrested and denied all rights in the cells.
Let us know the outcome its time everyone took a stand against this type of behavior.
Charles Tregoning (Shield Tours)
—– Original Message —–
Should the police be allowed to continue with this bullying tactics we can be sure that we will become a Police State, unless of course we all take a stand as Tour Operators,
As Ambassadors of SA we canmot sit and relax.
We are making a descent living and promoting our beautiful country to the rest of world.
We have to be very honest that the system sticks and the officials are totally arrogant incompetient and greedy, and lazy.. it is becoming more frightening for us female tour guides to operate without getting into some sorts of trouble with these highways robbers.
We still have the power to take a stand, so we can collectly spread the word and warn people lets continue to oppose this lawlessness before the tourist become warned about travelling to our country.
The police are here to serve the nation and not vice versa
The internet is a powerful tool lets use it.
Also make sure we record whatever information we need to nail these robbers.
Dear Martin
I’m so sorry to hear about your run-in with the law. As Dickens said “The Law is an ass”.
Michael also had a set to with the police today – a woman drove into the back of his car this morning – she had two children in the car and only a ( very new) learner’s licence – so no insurance. When he reported the accident to the police – to enable him to claim on HIS insurance, he asked if he could lay a charge against the woman driver as she had been breaking the law by driving without a qualified driver in the car, and by having passengers, he was told no, she had to be arrested by the traffic police for that!
We live in a crazy world.
We are most distressed to read of your experience at the hands of our local constabulary, just can’t understand how they “let the side down” so badly sometimes, while one reads of other instances where they have offered most satisfactory service to the public.
Delighted to see the local Herald gave you front page coverage, let’s hope the police learn a lesson from your unfortunate experience and modify their approach to the public.(Or am I living in a dream world).
Kind regards,
Mike
Jammer Martin, dat so iets met jou moes gebeur. Dit laat mens so magteloos voel dat jy uitgelewer is aan mense wat hulle posisie misbruik tot hulle eie voordeel.
Sterkte vir jou.
Groete,
Truida Pretorius van Aloe Eden.
Hello Martin.
I was very saddened to hear about your unfortunate ordeal. However, because of your ordeal and because I sincerely hope you get your justice in court, I do believe these things should come to the attention of our new President. How will he ever be able to do his job properly if he is unaware of these happenings.
I believe he should be bombarded with all the wrong doings in our country of all the people who work for the government and get down and do the job as promised………
Shelly
Dear Martin
How you hit the nail on the head. Grass route level changes are the only things that are going to initiate improvements.
As they say in Afrikaans, “STERKTE” for your court appearance which will probably be postponed ad infinitum.
Regards
Carol
Hi Martin
Strength Bro, glad there are those around that will stand up against the tide.
Alfred
Hi Martin,
I really feel sorry for you on the one hand, on the other hand it is good to get this things reported in a wider auditorium.
Yes, SA has lot of space for improvement and the police on the lower level should recognize that they have not to misuse their position.
Hope the court case went in your favour.
Regards
Bernhard
Leave A Reply