Did you know that the term ‘price gouging’ actually warrants a Wikipedia entry? No really, you’ll find it here. And it seems that some people actually support the concept.
“The term is similar to profiteering but can be distinguished by being short-term and localized, and by a restriction to essentials such as food, clothing, shelter, medicine and equipment needed to preserve life, limb and property. In jurisdictions where there is no such crime, the term may still be used to pressure firms to refrain from such behavior.
“Some support the ability to raise prices under such circumstances, asserting that government prohibition of the practice is a violation of individual rights or that the ability to raise prices has beneficial effects or both. While some economists who defend the practice use the term ‘price gouging’, others disparage it as merely pejorative.’
Wikipedia is silent, however, on the effects of short term price increases on countries and destinations in the tourism industry.
South Africa is in the grip of World Cup fever, and I fear that the ilness has made many of us delirious - so much so that we can’t see what we’re doing to ourselves.
I’ve been talking about this for some time now, but correspondence arrived in my in-box last week that was more than just theoretical - it was real. So, rather than arguing against unrealistic price increases, I thought I might let the mails talk for themselves (and please note - this is not an attack on the inbound operator. These are the actual quotes he received. Read them - and the client’s response - and make up your own mind).
MAIL FROM A READER TO THIS TOURISM WEEK:
Hi Martin
I have a client who has tickets to watch the Australia games at the world cup. He asked us to arrange accommodation and some game viewing at lodges after the tournament.
Here is my request to a major inbound tour operator with a specialist team working only on World Cup enquiries - and the response I received:
We require 2 rooms in the following cities on the following dates: Johannesburg: 15 June – 1 night; Bloemfontein: 16 & 17 June – 2 nights; Sun City/Rustenburg 18, 19, 20 & 21 – 4 nights; Polokwane 22 June – 1 night; Nelspruit 23, 24 & 25 June – 3 nights
We also need to try and fit in some game lodges…
++++++++++++++++++++
THE RESPONSE FROM THE OPERATOR
Thank you for your request. I would just like to advise that 90% of hotels, game lodges and guest houses have a minimum night stay requirement for the World Cup period.
The minimums are 3 nights, 4 nights and 7 nights at most places. I am busy looking at availability for you and will send you a email with properties that are available with what there minimum night is. With the ones that have 7 nights we can negotiate with the properties but only once clients confirm.
Please see our quote below:
Johannesburg: 15 June – 1 night
Holiday Inn Sandton (Standard rooms) @ R4,400.00 per room per night, bed and breakfast basis. 3 night minimum required.
Bloemfontein: 16 & 17 June – 2 nights
Orchards Guest house (Standard rooms) @ R 2,750.00 per room per night, bed and breakfast. 3 night minimum required.
Sun City/Rustenburg: 18, 19, 20 & 21 – 4 nights
Koster country house (standard rooms) @ R 4,840.00 per room per night, dinner bed and breakfast. 2 night minimum required.
Polokwane : 22 June – 1 night
Mashovhela Lodge (standard rooms) @ R 2,576.00 per room per night, dinner bed and breakfast. 2 night minimum required.
Nelspruit: 23, 24 & 25 June – 3 nights
Ant and Elephant lodge (standard rooms) @ R 1,380.00 per room per night bed and breakfast basis. No minimum nights required
I have not booked anything yet, and the above accommodation is subject to availability at the time of booking. Please note that should we be able to get rooms for you, we will provisionally hold the accommodation for 48 hours. Once you have paid in full for the accommodation, we will confirm the accommodation to you and send you the voucher.
++++++++++++++++++++
MAIL FROM THE READER:
To the Inbound Tour Operator
Thanks you for this. I have passed it on to my clients but doubt very much that they will accept being ripped off as this does. Not only are the prices simply stupid but the minimum night stays just add to what is already a farcical price – even before we add any mark up for our efforts. South Africa will live to regret this greed and avarice and will pay in the future as travellers are being ripped off big time and the word will spread rapidly and they will not return nor will they recommend South Africa for future holidays to their friends. South Africa should use this opportunity as a springboard to future tourism and not as an opportunity for short term gain!
This happened to Sydney with the 2000 Olympics and they are still paying the price as tourism was badly affected after the Olympics and the effects are still apparent!
Anyway this is none of your doing so I guess all I can do is express my views in the vain hope that someone might become aware of this sentiment.
++++++++++++++++++++
AND HERE’S WHAT THE CLIENT THOUGHT ABOUT ALL OF THIS:
Hi John,
Love the e-mail.
It’s true they are blatantly gouging all visitors and it is leaving a sour taste in our mouths.
I think our best option is to wait until closer to the date as I believe there are not too many suckers out there who will pay these rates.
Let talk again in a couple of months.
Regards
Chris
++++++++++++++++++++
And really, after that - there’s not much more to say, is there?
New Management for George’s Oakhurst Hotel
Well-known Mossel Bay hotelier JJ Moorcroft (the creator of the award-winning Protea Hotel Mossel Bay) has taken over management of George’s Oakhurst Hotel. He will be assisted by Erica Valentyn, who served for more than 12 years with the Garden Route’s private sector marketing organisation, Gartour.
The 25-room, 3-star Oakhurst Hotel, which has been built in the thatched tradition of a fine Cape manor house, is situated in a quiet side street at the centre of George, the Southern Cape’s capital city.
“We market the hotel under the slogan ‘Urban Tranquility in the Heart of George,’ because there really is no better way of describing it,” said Mr. Moorcroft.
The hotel has positioned itself - both physically and in its marketing campaigns - to attract tour groups, holidaymakers and businesspeople.
“There are no less than ten restaurants within walking distance of our front door, we’re child-friendly, we’ve tied up an agreement with a spa right next door to us, and, of course, George is right in the heart of all the attractions that make the Garden Route great - the golf, the mountains, and the sea - so Oakhurst falls naturally into the touring and holiday markets,” said Mr. Moorcroft.
“But the Conference Market is also an interesting one for us. We’re linked with The Office, a conference facility about two blocks away - so our guests are conveniently close to their meeting rooms, and their guests can either stay with us or eat their meals with us.”
The hotel offers three types of en suite bedroom. One ground floor room has been designed for the disabled; 12 Standard Rooms have twin or double beds; and 13 Deluxe Rooms are situated on the upper floor of the two-storey structure, and have lounges or bunk beds in their loft areas - which tuck in under the thatch of the roof.
Many of the rooms face the Outeniqua Mountains - which tower over George - and all are air-conditioned and supplied with stylish modern amenities. And whilst George is correctly classified as a city, the fynbos-covered mountains give the town a feeling of being in the country - a feeling that has informed the atmosphere and furnishings of both the bedrooms and the public areas at Oakhurst.
“Oakhurst has an outdoor swimming pool and patio, a lounge with a large farmhouse fireplace, a ladies bar, secure open parking, and wireless internet, and our restaurant is open for breakfasts, lunch and snacks throughout the day - so it’s become a popular meeting place for local businesspeople, too,” said Mr. Moorcroft
Ms. Valentyn, who came to George from Johannesburg in 1997, and particularly enjoys coordinating weddings and conferences, said that she relishes the idea of putting new properties on the map.
“I am so excited by Oakhurst because the hotel is of a very high standard, and I know that every guest will be more than satisfied,” she said.
Visit the Oakhurst Hotel on line at www.oakhursthotel.co.za - and watch an interview with JJ Moorcroft below
Now go away on holiday - it’s in the economy’s best interests









21 users commented in " More 2010 Pricing Woes "
Follow-up comment rss or Leave a TrackbackHi Martin
In response to your article about price gouging I couldnt agree more that rates are stupid however there are two points I would like to highlight that are never mentioned that would often explain why some rates are stupid.
1 Many properties in sought after suburbs of major cities have set the trend by listening to match and the press about how much this property went for and suddenly they all think they can mark their rates up 400% so the rot strarts here.
Secondly many tour operaors and travel agents thought that the properties they have supported for many years woyld give them rooms to sell.
However other operators secured accommodation over a year ago to sell to there clients.
Now it is crunch time and their are many opertaors who are being over run with enquires and have no accommodation secured so have no option to purchase from another operator who in turn has bought from another operator and so the chain grows.
So in conclusion if you have 3 operators in the chain making 10 or 15 % the end user will pay double
A quick example the first operator buys at R2000 sell at 15% = R2352, he sell at 15% on R2352 = R2768, he sell to operator overseas at 15% margin = R3256 and he sell to the end user at 15% = R 3830 to the end user.
And Actually no one in the chain has made a unreasonable mark up it is the nature of the event and many operators were caught with their pants down.
Cheers
Al
I agree with the above. FIFA Match has driven the prices up and lots of establishments believed that MATCH would deliver on its promise but reading any reviews on the cup in Germany, one could have known that this wouldn’t happen. And what happens now? They gave back 60.000 room nights I believe here in the Western Cape only! They can’t sell the rooms themselves. Please let us just rather all focus on 2011 and 2012 and don’t be blinded by 1 month of Soccer World Cup. It’s a FANTASTIC opportunity to showcase the country for AFTER the event!!
I managed to secure rooms directly for my clients last year February and yes in a top 5 star establishment I have very reasonable prices when I compare this to the above (ZAR 4800 per room per night including a 4 course dinner in their top restaurant for 100 delegates). All I’m going to do, is to focus on making this the most wonderful experience EVER for these corporate groups so that they will all come back next year and bring their entire families on a 3 week holiday throughout the country. That’s what this WC should be about, I think..
Hi Martin. I think it’s a combination of stupidity, greed and to a large extent ignorance that causes the decision makers to hike the rates the way some of them have.
Athens have the same problem that Syney have as a result of price gouging. Interestingly enough, I heard the other day that Barcelona are still reaping the rewards of the Olympics because they didn’t go the price gouging route. If my memory serves me correctly the Olympics were held there in 1992. Why don’t we learn from them?????????
One aspect of your newsletter stood out for me and that was that fans are going to bide their time. Closer to the world cup many more rooms will become available. Of that there is no doubt. They will discount. My question is this, what do you tell a guest who’s paid 500% more for their room only to find out there are other guests who paid the normal rates. I don’t want to have to face that thank you very much.
Martin good mail from Australia.
This is what I was trying to tell you in my previous mail to you.
Sooth African business people have gotten too greedy, combined with arrogance and stupidity.
You have a good newsletter and I trust will use this as an instrument to invoke change , no matter how small… it will help.
It would be great to see the image change. Currently as I said the Europeans are not overly impressed. They may have a good holiday, but that’s separated from the peoples business behaviour.
Gruß
Nalin
Dear Richard - thanks for putting this up to the site.
I had another insight this week - nowhere have I seen any studies on the demographics of the World Cup Traveller, and this is an awful mistake. A friend of mine, a consultant to South American Governments, said that from the experience of Germany in 2006, the demographic was probably blue-collar males 25-32 years old, travelling in groups of like-minded young men. I think this makes sense. But it’s an explosive group. If my friend is right, this is going to be a troublesome year - especially as that’s not the wealthiest group of people, and they are certainly not going to pay 450 pounds a night to stay in larney hotels. They’re going to want to be where the parties are, and screw the safaris and the sedate and genteel guest lodges with cheffy weffies producing tiny portions of exquisitely arranged food on massive and expensive china platters.
As you say, “I think it’s a combination of stupidity, greed and to a large extent ignorance that causes the decision makers to hike the rates the way some of them have.”
The first thing we should have done was study our market. How could we not have?
Hi Martin,
I laughed when I read the quote from the Tour Operator for the World Cup. Firstly, they need to buy a map because the Ant & Elephant (www.antandelephant.co.za) is in Hazyview, 75kms from Nelspruit!! Secondly, they (Ant & Elephant) haven’t increased their rates for the World Cup and haven’t contracted to Match or anybody else for that matter. And their rates are R320 p/p nett B&B!! He’s busy installing air-conditioning into all the rooms so it could be as high as R340 p/p B&B by June!! The owner says that he’s in the business for at least the next 5 years not just for June & July!!
Cheers,
Tracey
AFRICAN SAFARI ADVENTURES
Martin,
Very much agree glad to see its time to wake up! Just hope its not going to put the tourists off! (although price is just one of the aspects that keeps people away)
We (at Kololo Game Reserve) are maintaining our rates per normal structure, just packaged into 2 night packages. We also believe people are asking exorbitant rates, we’re all ambassadors and we should use this as a chance to showcase SA as a good value for money destination! For info: our rates start from R3500 for 2 nights, all meals and (Big 5) game drives included, as a result with getting many people booking us direct and even using us as a base for their duration of stay!
Thanks for sending it out there and givingthe people that want to do this ‘properly’ a chance to do so!
Best Regards,
Emlyn - Sales Manager Kololo Game Reserve
Hi Martin,
Thank you for “This Tourism Week” news letter. It is very informative and helpful.
I just want to say, this is going to hurt us all, even the ones who did not load their prices. Gouging is going to lead to disaster in the accommodation industry.
Although we are a graded and well placed establishment, we do not ask these prices and we do a lot more for our clients. Please refer some of these clients, I am sure they will love our prices… And services!!!
Hi Martin,
Hereunder my conversation with a 4* hotel in CPT …… I fully agree with what you gave as an example !!!
Myriam Wambacq
GREENHAVEN TOURS cc
PO Box 15593
Port Elizabeth 6011
Tel & Fax +27 (0)41 379 21 64
Cell 082 61 33 259
VAT 4710 241 631
Please visit us at http://www.greenhaven.co.za
Please consider the environment before printing this email
Dear Myriam,
Thanks for your earlier reservation and this mail:
Our STO rates for Greenhaven tours are as follows:
01/05/2010 to 06 June 2010 and 15 July to 30 September: R630.00 Single ; R 890.00 Double ; 1 October 2010 to 30 September 2011: R690.00 Single ; R495.00 pp Sharing B&B ( R990.00 twin or double ); ( Rack Rate R920.00 single ; R655.00 per person sharing B&B )
May 2010 be a great one for you. PS I do still have 2010 world Cup rooms available at R2500.00 per room, single or double, B&B. Please advise what your thoughts are on this pricing and if you know of anyone who may be interested in blocks of rooms in particular. Your comment will be appreciated. I thank you in anticipation Myriam – my valued partner in tourism.
Kind regards
Colin
Thanks Colin !
You want my honest opinion on the World Cup ? Here we go ( although I don’t have any clients interested in coming, this kind of event is not our market )…
I think many hotels rooms all over the country will stay empty for several reasons : sales overseas are far less than expected and the kind of crowd attending this sport are not the ones staying in 4* or 5* ( unless corporate invites and there too : the interest is very low ). South Africa – in general – is being too greedy by doubling or tripling their room rates. Same thing for the guides. I spoke to some of them : they ask 4 times their normal day rate. Are they 4 times better during these days ? Are hotel rooms 4 times better ? Service 4 times better ? Transport ? Tourists – and I’m talking overseas people – are not stupid …. They compare rates for – let’s say – January and then for the World Cup and they see the increase. They feel betrayed. And they are absolutely right !
My feelings are that this whole World Cup thing is going to bring tourism business down for the coming 2 years. I hope the future will prove me wrong.
Warm regards,
Myriam Wambacq
GREENHAVEN TOURS cc
Dear Myriam
Thank you for your prompt, honest and much appreciated feedback, which I should have asked for long ago. One of my reasons for the higher rates has been out of fear of being too attractive, by comparison to other hotels, and then having the problem if our Hotel is the cheapest, of having, and attracting the wrong crowd. I have been hoping to attract groups / corporates who like the safer and quieter location.
If you do know of anyone who might be interested in rooms for corporates, groups or supporters, whom are not likely to tear our little village to pieces, please know that I will gladly sell our rooms at R1500.00 per room, Single or Double.
Thanks again Myriam for your trusted thoughts, and I sincerely hope that this World Cup, and South Africa’s handling of it, does not do us damage.
Kind regards
Hi Martin,
thanks for the tourism week Newsletter which I always read with great interest.
Do you have any actual experience with the bookings for guest houses which are not so close to the cities where the World Cup will take place.
E.g. we in Plett are 220 km away from PE and 550 km from Cape Town.
We don’t have any enquiry yet for the World Cup.
Is it the same situation with other Guest Houses with similar location?
Best regards
Bernhard
Dear Bernhard
Good to hear from you and best wishes for the rest of this year, which I think is going to be a troublesome one.
I don’t think many people in the country areas have had enquiries for the World Cup. I also don’t think the government or anyone else has done any research into the demographics of the World Cup supporters. I would assume we’re looking at males 25 - 32 years old, and I expect they’ll be travelling in groups with their male friends, rather than with their girlfriends. That’s an explosive situation, if you ask me. I also believe they’ll stay in the cities, where the parties (and the games, but they’re secondary for many of the supporters) will be held.
As far as I know, very few guest houses or hotels in our area have had any bookings or even enquiries for that period
Take care,
Thanks and
With best Barefoot Wishes - M
MARTIN HATCHUEL, Barefoot Writer
Dear Martin
I guess SA is going to learn it the hard way: If a country has outpriced itself of a market (Sydney learned this after the 2000 Olympics, Hongkong after the transition) it’s extremely difficult to re-convince people on a destination or venue.
We are watching what’s going on closely and we now are receiving “specials” as obviously some venues/TA have just overstretched expectations and are now facing reality.
Good for those!
The destination and its players must understand it’s not just the high rates and fares. That combined with the anticipation of further increase of crime rate makes people reluctant to travel to South Africa between May and Sep - at least on our end it’s the case.
As we are dedicated to photographic safaris and outr clients are very sensitive in view to animal abuse South Africa’s reputation has been emaged tremendously because of the planned Elephant culling in Kruger, the Seal clubbing and predominantly the CANNED HUNTING SCANDAL!
Despite there is hope because of the upcoming court case many of our clients fear that the new legislation is simply “window dressing” and does offer more loopholes to those who are involved in this unethical and bloody “sports”.
Best regards
Irma
Just to add a link to a travel forum which actually exposes some really interesting sentiments:
http://www.fodors.com/community/africa-the-middle-east/fifa-world-cup-shock.cfm
Hi Martin,
Well this has certainly stirred up a few strong feelings. I did not expect this reaction when I wrote to you but it does show that many people feel the same way we do!
Tracey’s response gave me great big smile. Thanks Tracey! You are dead right!
However let me assure your readers that South Africa will always remain a key focus for us as our clients come back with hugely positive feedback without exception. I am still to receive a negative feedback report on South Africa. The World Cup has certainly focussed the spotlight on SA and I sincerely hope it all ends in the most positive of ways.
Cheers mate.
John
Hi Martin,
We read all of this “price gouging” stuff with interest. I know that one stop shopping is convenient but maybe people must cut out the tour operators and do some research themselves.
We are a 3 star graded establishment in Magoebaskloof (45 minutes drive from Peter Mokaba stadium in Polokwane) and our prices to stay in a fully equipped self catering cottage in beautiful settings – mountains, forests, gardens with pool etc, are R250 per person per night, without minimum stay requirements except over a weekend. There are many attractions in the area and we are just 1.5 hours easy drive from the Phalaborwa gate of the Kruger Park.
So what I am really saying is that there are reasonable options about but unfortunately people have to do a little organizing themselves – the savings could make it worthwhile!!
Kind regards,
Alf
Cheerio Trout Fishing & Holiday Resort.
Hi Martin,
Your letter and it’s contents are all very much reality. We are overestimating the influx of football fanatics and underestimating the world-wide recession that is still very much alive. Do not compare the visitors figures at the last tournament in Germany, since most visitors simply hopped in their cars and drove to the stadium from all over Europe. Now everyone has to hop in a plane and that costs slightly more than a tank of fuel for the Polo.
I operate a motorhome rental company and we were always secured of a full utilisation during World Cup time. Eventhough we knew this, we still sold them all with our standard low season tariff. June had always been a very quiet month since the European summer holidays only start in July.
My philosophy: We are never busy during June. Now we are. For this we are grateful and that should be enough.
Let us provide a service and accomodation the way we always do it - and at the rate we are accustomed to. That will make a football supporter (many who would otherwise not have visited SA) a repeat customer and that will generate long-term turnover which is more important than short-term profit. That’s the way my dad has taught me.
Kind Regards,
Tim Bouwers
Bobo Campers SA
Dear Martin
Thank you for your newsletter. I note that our Lodge is being quoted by the Operator as in Mashovhela Lodge and being ridiculously over priced. Our rack daily rates for Dinner, bed and breakfast (as quoted) are R635 per person per night ie R1270 and nett to an operator at R508 ie R1016.00 – so the operator buys our room at R1016 and is selling it at R2576.00 which is more than a 150% mark up. No wonder the international reader feels he is being ripped off.
Mashovhela has developed packages for the world cup, and yes we do have a minimum nights, but we believe our packages are advantageous to clients as they will arrive at our lodge the night before the game, the following day we will take them to the football and return to the lodge and then the next day show them the area.
If your reader would like to contact me directly I might be able to sort out his Polokwane leg for him.
Kind regards
Pete
I loved this article you should send it to the Sunday Times or something!! Everyone should be aware of this…
I have practically given up on the World Cup!! I am trying to arrange a holiday in Mauritius during this crazy time! I refuse to bow to MATCH and their “mafia price wars” as well as ripping off my clients who may wish to travel to South Africa. I have struggled to find accommodation for some prospective clients in Johannesburg [8 couples who want to spend only 3 nights in Johannesburg in 5star luxury] Do you think I can find anything? I have also contacted the biggest tour operator in South Africa who is holding rooms as well in some of the major hotels. Their response is that all the 5star hotels are fully booked and all want a minimum night stay of 6 nights or more!! This is absolutely ludicrous as clients want to see all of South Africa not just 1 city!!!
I am honestly focusing on tours to South Africa for before and after the World Cup!
Quite honestly I hate the game of soccer and don’t see what all the fuss is about! We are planning to visit New Zealand next year to watch the Springboks at the rugby world cup! That’s worth spending money on and getting excited about!
Dont’ get me wrong! I think the soccer world cup is a great achievement for South Africa and something to be proud of! but don’t lose yourselves in the idea of “making lots of money”! we need people to return and feel our warm hospitality!
Sadly I am not surprised at what is happening -there seems to be a cancer in this country where we stuff up everything that is good by our stupidity and greed.
Just for your info, we are charging our normal rates over the world cup - R550 per person for luxury and R450.00 per person for standard suites. We did debate the minimum nights issue but decided that for a guest house, this would not be a good idea and we are treating the world cup just like any other period.
Kind regards,
Alan Woolnough
Saxon Lodge
Gansbaai
Hi
This is my classic World Cup rip off
I phoned the Polokwane Royal to check availability for 1 night (17 June)and great, they could assist at a rate of R 4860 B&B, (gasp.. splutter). I then asked what the rate would be if my clients were to travel in APril and the reply was R760 B&B, well with about a 500% mark up (and no website to even look at), I will certainly NOT be booking my clients in there EVER.
Wonder if they will be around in 2 years???
Only read the first mail example you gave – SHOCKING. We have contracted to Match for The World Cup and were allowed a max. of 16% increase on 2007 rates. The reason – TRYING TO MANAGE EXACTLY WHAT HAS BECOME THE PROBLEM. In reality it has meant that our rates for the world cup are at about our 2010 peak season rate which in my opinion is great considering what occupancy we normally have during June and July.
Another example of South Africans shooting themselves in the foot (or is it HEAD!!)
Kind regards
In 2000 many Zambia lodges put huge mark ups on their accommodation rates in a bid to profit from the Eclipse. Any many were empty.
I just had my group of 20 from Tampa cancel their 3 week tour (SA and Zambia) due to the crazy prices for accommodation and flights being charged in SA.
There are no winners when we only look for short term gain.
R
Leave A Reply